Rule Proposal: Player Waiver Period
-
So the biggest deal in the NBA today seem to be whether Zydrunas Ilguaskas will return to the Cleveland Cavaliers after sitting out for thirty days.
After being traded from the Cavs to the Washington Wizards, as the primary piece of the puzzle to bring on Jamison alongside Lebron James, Ilguaskas has been bought out by the Washington Wizards. According to league rules, he is allowed to openly negotiate and sign with any team in the league (likely a competitor) or he can sit out for thirty days in order to rejoin his previous team, the Cavaliers.
The internet has seen millions of posts since this trade took place with speculation that the Wizards would buy out Ilguaskas and he would simply return to the Cavs. In my opinion, Cavs management is probably well aware of the rules, and if not, has heard the rumblings from around the internets, and knew that trading away the big 7’3″ center to fill a void in the roster wasn’t a big deal because they would simply resign him after a month vacation.
My problem with this, just like the rest of the GM’s and coaches in the league, is that who’s to say Cleveland didn’t agree with Ilgauskas prior to the trade that he would return to the team after being waved by the Wizards. Everyone know he wasn’t going to play a single game in Washington, and yet, the possibility of the Cavs giving away nothing for Jamison didn’t seem to be a problem.
Since Ilguaskas has been waived, yes, an entire two days, we have heard that teams such as the Denver Nuggets and Atlanta Hawks are extremely interested in his services. In fact, the Hawks have even reportedly made an offer to the veteran center.
I knew the rules heading into the trade, I knew what to expect, and yet, I was still angry about the way it turned out. As a Lakers fan, it would’ve been the equivalent of acquiring Pau Gasol and getting Marc Gasol back (not quite the same, Cavs still get the better deal).
Anyway, I realized that the entire league and blogosphere was angry about the situation (except for the Cavs fans, of course), and figured I would just let it go. BUT, not I have been angered even further.
As I was getting my daily fix of NBA news on RealGM, I stumbled upon the following: “He knows I would love for him to be back here. I want him to be back here, especially while we’re contending for a title,” LeBron James said. “He’s one of the main reasons why I want to win a title for this team.”
Suddenly, it struck me, I’ve got a rule change proposal! No, not a Jeff Van Gundy rule proposal where if a player makes a shot from half court at any time during the game, it automatically becomes a tie game, but a real rule. A rule to help make things just a bit more fair.
It’s been exactly one day since Ilguaskas has become a free agent. The rules currently state that he can join any team, but in order to join his previous team, in this case the Cavaliers, he must sit out for thirty days.
I propose the following: During that thirty day period, said player who was waived, is not allowed to communicate or negotiate with any players, management, owners or “sources” from his previous team. This also shall include members of his previous team reaching out to him, whether personally, or through the media.
Yes, I understand it is nearly impossible to enforce Lebron James from making a personal phone call to Ilgauskas and telling him to come back, but thats not different then a team making an under the table agreement with a player prior to a trade. How do we know Danny Ferry didn’t make the deal only because he already had an agreement with Ilguaskas that he would return after he was waived. After all, with Cleveland having all that momentum heading into the trade deadline, wouldn’t they want to bring back a key piece to their team?
What do you think? Is it possible to prevent that player from having any relations with his former team? Doesn’t it make more sense to give other teams an advantage? If a player decides he wants to risk sitting out for thirty days and his old team not wanting him, that’s his choice; but, at least with this rule, they can’t come to terms with their former team and agree to sit out thirty days knowing they are guaranteed a roster spot.



February 27th, 2010 at 1:27 pm
Well I think the Cavs would also have to have an agreement with the other team to buy Ilgauskas out for him to even have a chance at returning to Cleveland. But here are my suggestions:
A team that has no intentions of keeping an acquired player and plans on buying out his contract that the team must wait 30 days to buy out his contract then the player must wait another 30 days before he signs with his previous team. Plus, the team will also have to double the price of buying out the remainder of the player’s contract.
Or
The traded and bought out player cannot sign with his previous team until the immediate off-season but is allowed to sign with any team looking to add a player in their roster for only the remainder of the season, including playoffs.
Or
Any traded player that’s been bought out will not be eligible for playoff participation if he signs with his previous team in the same season.
Or
Any player that’s been bought out after a trade then signs with his previous team can only be signed for a maximum of three 10-day contracts. After that, the player is no longer eligible to play for his previous team but must wait until the immediate off-season to sign a one-year contract at the salary that is on his original contract for the following season or for the current season if the player had an expiring contract plus 15% of the final year of the player’s original contract.
Or
The traded and bought out player must wait a full 60 days before re-signing with his previous team. His previous team must re-sign him for the full season’s salary of that same year he was traded and bought out plus only a one-year extension as the team’s option. But the team must give the player the same salary owed to him the following year of his original contract or the same salary as the final year of his expiring contract PLUS 15% of the final year of his original contract.